The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) believes that telehealth is supplementary rather than a replacement for face-to-face consultations. According to Medicare guidelines, telehealth services have the same clinical criteria as face-to-face consultations, but face-to-face assessments are preferable when clinical benefits exist.
MJAThese days, there are many options for seeing a doctor in Australia. With modern technology, you can consult a GP or a psychiatrist via telephone or video calls. Face-to-face visits have, however, remained an option, and not surprisingly so.
Convenience is important, but it doesn’t decide everything. Some consultations lend themselves well to telemedicine, while others require something more thorough and done in person. This is helpful information to keep in mind.
In this article, we will go through what telehealth and in-clinic services consist of, compare their pros, cons, and cost, and review when each type works best depending on health needs in Adelaide.
Key Takeaways:
- Telehealth is convenient and helps increase accessibility of healthcare services for people from regional locations, with mobility issues, or a busy schedule.
- In-clinic care implies physical exam and clinical assessment, which cannot be performed within telehealth appointments.
- Medicare covers both telehealth services via phone or video and in-person visits in accordance with eligibility criteria.
- New or changing symptoms, injuries, developmental testing (such as ADHD or autism), and complicated cases of mental health need to be seen in clinic.
- Consistent and stable health conditions, reviewing medications, following up after tests, and discussing results are appropriate cases for telehealth.
- It is typical for people to use both telehealth and in-person visits in most situations depending on their needs.
What is Telehealth?
Telehealth is the delivery of medical services remotely via phone, video, or other secure digital platform, instead of face-to-face. Specifically, it can include:
- A video consultation with your GP or psychiatrist
- A phone consultation for a quick review or a results discussion
- Secure messaging for straightforward questions between appointments
This is nothing new in itself, but its use grew significantly during the COVID-19 period when Australians had to get care from their homes. Since then, it has been accepted as a permanent fixture of the healthcare system rather than a temporary one.
Clinicians use telehealth for follow-ups, medication management, reviewing test results, referral management, and providing general advice. Telehealth is especially useful in regional and rural areas in South Australia, where the closest expert can be quite far away.
However, there is a limit to telehealth. A physician cannot feel the patient’s abdomen, examine their reflexes, or observe the movement and interactions of the child over the screen.
What Is the Key Benefit of Telehealth?
If there’s one standout advantage, it’s accessibility. Telehealth lets you consult a healthcare professional without setting foot in a clinic, saving time, cutting travel costs, and making care easier to reach when an in-person visit isn’t practical.
That matters most for:
- For those living in regions or rural areas, whose only choice would be an extensive journey to the doctor’s office or specialist
- Individuals with restricted mobility, for whom simply travelling to the clinic poses a problem
- People who have a tight schedule that makes it hard to plan an appointment
Patients with a controllable and chronic condition that calls for them to be examined on a frequent basis without any need for further diagnosis.
It helps patients stay connected with their doctors during illness when it is not convenient to travel. Moreover, telehealth decreases the chances of virus transmission to other patients and hospital personnel because one cannot spend time in the waiting area while sick.
When is Telehealth Helpful?
For the most part, telehealth suits:
- Follow-up consultations
- Discussion of test results
- Medication management and reviews
- General health advice
- Referral discussions
- Managing stable, previously diagnosed conditions
In such cases, the practitioner would have sufficient context about you to assist you effectively without needing a physical examination.
Drawbacks of Telehealth
Telehealth has several benefits, although it is not suited for everybody and every situation.
No physical examination: Physical exams such as auscultation of the chest and examining wounds cannot be performed through telehealth.
Access limitations: Requires access to the technology and the internet, thus putting disadvantaged groups, such as elderly and poor people, at a disadvantage.
Privacy at home: Not all patients have a quiet and private place where a personal conversation may take place.
Insufficiencies in complicated and developmental situations: Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and autism cannot be diagnosed by telehealth.
What Is In-Clinic Care?
In-clinic care is in-person healthcare conducted in a clinic setting with a GP, psychiatrist, psychologist or other health care professional opposite you.
In a typical in-person encounter, there is more involved than discussing your symptoms. The clinician in the same room will be able to notice the way you sit and move, which is something patients tend not to think about mentioning themselves.
In-person care offers physical examinations and clinical tests that aren’t available online. Whether it concerns your physical, psychological, or developmental health or all at once, an in-person encounter will allow the clinician to get the complete picture.
Also, in-person care allows you to establish a degree of trust with the clinician that helps you open up.
When In-Person Care Is the Better Choice
In-person is usually the right call for:
- New or unexplained symptoms
- Injuries
- Developmental assessments, including ADHD and autism
- Detailed mental health assessments
- Neurological concerns
- Complex or overlapping conditions
- Anything that needs a physical examination
When a clinician needs to see, assess, or examine you directly, an in-person appointment almost always gives a clearer picture.
The Benefits of In-Person Care
The in-person treatment method has some distinct advantages that are irreplaceable with telehealth:
- More accurate physical evaluation: Information is collected using observation, movement, and physical examination, which cannot be achieved via screens
- More human connection: During in-person consultations, body language is evaluated fully, and it’s easier for patients to open up personally
- Access to diagnostics immediately: Some cases require special equipment or testing to get immediate results
- Development of a more personalised treatment plan: It starts from the patient’s identification, revealing more personal aspects and helping develop a suitable plan
The following features are why in-person treatment usually has more importance regarding diagnosis and treatment plan formation despite being less convenient compared to telehealth.
Telehealth vs In-Person Care: The Key Differences
| Features | Telehealth | In-Clinic Care |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | No travel; join from home, work, anywhere with internet | Requires travel; access to on-site facilities |
| Clinical assessment | Verbal and visual, over a screen | Full physical examination and direct observation |
| Best suited to | Follow-ups, medication reviews, results, stable conditions | New symptoms, injuries, complex or developmental assessments |
| Cost | Saves travel, fuel, parking and time off work | May cost more upfront but can reduce need for a follow-up visit |
| Continuity of care | Convenient, though rapport can build more slowly | Face-to-face contact tends to build trust faster |
| Medicare rebate | Available for eligible video and phone consultations | Available for eligible face-to-face consultations |
Accessibility
Telehealth takes travel out of the equation. You can join an appointment from home, the office, or wherever you happen to be. That’s a real advantage if you live far from healthcare services or find travel difficult.
In-clinic care asks more of your time and planning, but it opens up facilities, equipment, and assessments that simply aren’t possible remotely.
Clinical Assessment
This is where in-person care pulls ahead. Telehealth relies on what a clinician can hear and see through a screen; useful for a lot of situations, but no substitute for a hands-on physical examination or direct behavioural observation.
Patient Experience
People differ. Some find telehealth easier and more private. Others feel more comfortable speaking face-to-face, particularly about anything sensitive. Healthcare is personal, and the right format is the one that actually works for you.
Continuity of Care
A good practitioner-patient relationship is very important for quality care. This can be achieved fairly well through telehealth, but especially for chronic cases, in-person visits are better suited for this task.
Telehealth vs. In-Person Cost in Adelaide: What the Patient Needs to Know
Cost is always one of the main things patients are interested in when comparing telehealth and in-person visits. It is indeed an important factor; however, the quality of care should not be underestimated either.
The use of telehealth reduces travel expenses and saves working hours. But a cheaper appointment isn’t automatically the better one if it doesn’t gather what’s needed for a proper evaluation.
Sometimes a telehealth visit ends up followed by an in-person one anyway, in which case starting in person would have been both quicker and more cost-effective.
Medicare Telehealth: What Adelaide Patients Should Know
Medicare rebates cover both video and phone telehealth consultations, as well as face-to-face visits, under the Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS).
- Same clinical requirements and MBS benefit as the equivalent face-to-face item
- Video generally preferred, though phone remains a valid, rebated option
- Eligibility usually needs an existing relationship with your GP, via MyMedicare
- Bulk billing is at the provider’s discretion, same as in person
Since MBS rules are updated periodically, Services Australia’s telehealth billing information is the best source for current detail.
The bottom line: choose the appointment that fits the clinical need first. A follow-up visit you didn’t need usually costs more, in time and money, than getting it right the first time.
Telehealth for Psychiatry, ADHD and Autism Assessments
Mental health care is one area where telehealth genuinely earns its place, and one where its limits matter most.
Where it works well
Ongoing psychiatric review, medication management, and checking in on how a treatment plan is going. For patients who are stable on treatment, telehealth makes it far easier to stay consistent with care.
Where in-person still matters more
A full ADHD or autism assessment relies on structured observation, standardised testing and, especially for children, watching behaviour, communication and interaction directly. That’s genuinely hard to do through a screen.
The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners views telehealth as a complement, and not a replacement, to face-to-face care; a viewpoint that could be even more relevant here.
In essence, it often works best if a person first receives an in-person assessment to build a proper clinical picture, and only then has their progress reviewed using telehealth services after a treatment program is established.
Care That Fits the Person, Not Just the Diagnosis
Making good decisions about one’s healthcare requires more than just having sound clinical knowledge. A client-centred approach presupposes that your healthcare professional will consider your individual needs and preferences, including your preferred way of getting treatment.
It means that your healthcare professional will neither use telehealth services for convenience nor avoid meeting you in person due to long-established practice.
Your healthcare professional will help you assess what you truly need and make the right decision, which will improve communication and establish trust. It becomes crucial for people receiving care for their mental health conditions.
Telehealth Care Vs In-Person Care: Which is The Best
For Children and Families
In-person assessments usually have more success with children, as the practitioner can physically see behaviour, speech, and motor skills, which may be hard to see in video format but vital in a developmental evaluation.
Adults with Chronic Conditions Stably Managed
A good choice for follow-up appointments and medication management, though in-person visits remain important periodically in case of something missed over the phone.
For Mental Health Care
Ongoing support; medication reviews and check-ins during a stable period often work well by telehealth. An initial assessment, a crisis, or anything complex or unclear is usually better handled in person.
For Older Adults
An approach that includes multiple health issues needs a meticulous and hands-on evaluation. During personal visits, physicians can assess a patient’s physical abilities while providing the security many senior patients need.
Everyone who requires a thorough assessment. For all those cases when a comprehensive assessment is necessary, an in-person visit is a better option.
Having It All in One
There are very few people for whom the best solution would be either only telehealth or only in-person visits. Usually, a combination of both is the most optimal approach.
- Start with in-person visits when it is a new issue or a physical exam is needed
- Switch to telehealth for follow-ups and medication checkups after diagnosis
- Return to in-person visits when a closer look is needed
In this way, telehealth provides additional comfort without losing medical value.
Why Many Adelaide Patients Still Prefer In-Clinic Care
Despite how far telehealth has come, plenty of people in Adelaide still choose to see someone in person, and for good reason. Trust plays a big part: patients feel more confident when a clinician can assess them directly, notice small details, and give answers on the spot.
Personal connection matters too. Most people want a genuine, ongoing relationship with their doctor or psychiatrist, and that tends to form faster face-to-face.
How Elyséa HEALTH Facilitates Person-Centred In-Clinic Care in Adelaide
Person-centred healthcare is at the core of each consultation at Elyséa HEALTH. Taking the extra effort to learn what each patient needs, worries about, and hopes to achieve allows us to help people, not conditions.
With an emphasis on in-clinic psychiatry, psychology, and general practitioner consultations, we have the opportunities needed to conduct comprehensive evaluations and hold discussions that provide our practitioners with an overall understanding of our patients’ health status.
Why Patients Opt for Elyséa HEALTH
- Evidence-based care tailored to each patient’s needs
- In-clinic comprehensive assessments (ADHD and autism assessment)
- Person-centred healthcare approach
- Collaborative treatment planning
- Compassionate, experienced clinicians
Conclusion
There is no definitive solution in healthcare. Telehealth has increased access to care for a great number of Australians, and it certainly has its place, especially for consultations, prescribing medications, and patients who are truly restricted from travelling.
However, in-person care is an absolute must for those consultations that require a physical exam, a comprehensive developmental/diagnostic evaluation, or simply need a closer look. It is important to understand the actual distinctions, the costs involved, the clinical component, and what Medicare covers to make an informed decision.
FAQs
What is telehealth?
Healthcare delivered remotely by phone or video instead of a face-to-face visit; commonly used for follow-ups, medication reviews, and general health advice.
What is the key benefit of telehealth?
Accessibility. It removes the need to travel to a clinic, making care easier to reach for people in regional areas, with mobility limits, or with full schedules.
When should I use telehealth instead of an in-person appointment?
Telehealth suits stable, ongoing conditions, follow-ups, medication reviews and results discussions. New symptoms, injuries, developmental assessments and complex conditions are usually better handled in person.
Is telehealth as effective as in-person healthcare?
Extremely effective in check-up appointments and in drug monitoring and reporting. However, there is a wide variety of diseases that cannot be treated via telehealth, as they require a physical examination, as well as a developmental one.
What are the cons of telehealth?
The absence of a physical examination, the dependence on good technology and an Internet connection, limited privacy due to the need for a private room in the house, and difficulties with diagnosing complex and developmental conditions such as ADHD or autism.
Does Medicare cover telehealth in Australia?
Yes. Medicare rebates the services of video and phone telehealth consultations according to the same clinical criteria as its traditional equivalent. Eligibility for this program usually depends on a relationship with your GP and practice.
Is it possible to have an assessment of ADHD or autism by telehealth?
Continuous care and treatment may be provided via telehealth. However, an assessment of ADHD or autism requires an in-person structured assessment.
Elyséa HEALTH Website & Content Disclaimer
Information published on the Elyséa HEALTH website, including articles, blogs, and educational resources, is provided solely for general health information and wellbeing education. It does not constitute medical or psychiatric advice and is not a substitute for personalised assessment, diagnosis, or treatment by a qualified Australian healthcare professional. Accessing this website does not establish a clinician-patient relationship with this website or any of its practitioners.
The content on the website is for general information and may be prepared or reviewed by clinicians or the Elyséa HEALTH team. It is not a substitute for personalized medical advice. While we try to keep the information accurate and up to date, we cannot guarantee it is complete or suitable for your individual situation.
Always consult your own healthcare provider before making decisions about your health. We adhere to Australian healthcare advertising expectations, including principles consistent with AHPRA guidance. No outcomes, results, or treatment benefits are guaranteed.
Remember, this website is not for any emergency or crisis service. If you are in immediate danger, call 000.
Mental health crisis and support services in Australia include:
SA Mental Health Triage Service (24/7): 13 14 65
Lifeline: 13 11 14
Beyond Blue: 1300 224 636
Suicide Call Back Service: 1300 659 467
MensLine Australia: 1300 789 978
Kids Helpline: 1800 55 1800
Open Arms Veterans & Families Counselling: 1800 011 046
13YARN (First Nations support): 13 92 76
By using this website, you understand that the information is general and may change without notice.
